Blacks, Latinos Pay More for Mortgages
Compiled by DiversityInc
staff
© 2006 DiversityInc.com®
September 11, 2006
Black and Latino home buyers pay
more for their mortgages than do whites, according to a Federal Reserve report
released Friday.
The Fed's analysis of 2005
home-lending data found that 54.7 percent of black borrowers paid a
higher-than-typical interest rate on home mortgages. That was up sharply from
32.4 percent in 2004.
For Latinos, 46.1 percent paid
more than typical for their mortgages last year—more than double the 20.3
percent repoorted in 2004.
In contrast, only 17.2 percent of
whites paid higher interest on their home mortgages last year. However, that was
up considerably from 2004's 8.7 percent.
For all borrowers, there was a
"significant increase" in the incidents of higher priced mortgages from 24.6
percent in 2005 compared with 11.5 percent in 2004.
A number of factors were cited for
this overall increase. Mortgage rates in general were rising, and rates for
popular adjustable-rate mortgages in particular moved
higher.
And some borrowers stretching to
buy a home opted for creative financing, such as higher-priced piggyback loans.
The use of piggyback loans shot up more than 57 percent in 2005 from the prior
year, the Fed said.
"Indeed, the increase in the
number of higher-priced piggyback loans in 2005 accounted for more than half of
the increase in the number of all higher-priced loans," the report
said.
The report also said that black
borrowers applying for mortgages were more likely to be turned down than Latinos
and whites.
The report doesn't provide
interest rates charged to the different racial groups. It also doesn't include
information, such as the borrower's credit history, which is an important factor
in pricing a home mortgage.
Given that, economists and other
experts said one should be cautious about drawing any conclusions from the Fed
information about discriminatory lending.
Jay Brinkmann, a financial
economist at the Mortgage Bankers Association, said the price of a mortgage is
based on risk. The rise of high-priced loans in 2005—tthe last year of a
five-year housing boom—may be rellated to "borrowers in general having a somewhat
higher risk profile on average," he said. "In a sense, the best credit customers
stepped in early" in the housing-market boom, he said.
Still, the Fed report keeps the
debate alive for those concerned about racial and ethnic disparities in
financial services.
"We continue to face a national
problem in the fact that racial and ethnic differences mark different outcomes
in the acquisition of mortgages," said Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass. "I don’t not
believe this problem is caused solely by racial or ethnic prejudice, but it also
cannot be argued that these factors do not contribute to the
problem."
The Fed's report is based on
information from 8,848 financial institutions, which covers about 80 percent of
home lending nationwide. The Fed is required by Congress to report annually on
home-lending activity. (AP)